Pros and cons

  • Huge selection of promos and bonus offers
  • Wide range of banking options
  • Good sport selection
  • The welcome bonus requires a significant investment
  • Lengthy withdrawal process

Welcome Bonus

BetStar NJ’s new player sign up bonus of up to $500 is one of the most enticing sign up offers available to players in the Garden State. When placing your first bet with BetStars NJ, you will receive a free bet matched up to the value of $50. From this point onwards, for every $150 you wager, you’ll get another free bet of $50 up to the value of $450. So, to redeem the entire $500 bonus, you must wager a total of $1,350.

Compared to other top sports betting sites, this bonus is not as rewarding to new punters, as it requires new players to invest a hefty sum of money upfront to redeem the full value of the sign-up offer. Plus, it’s not exactly accessible for all – while the large initial investment required may not be a problem for high rollers, it may be outside the price range of some new punters and casual bettors.


  • Baseball
  • Basketball
  • Boxing
  • Football
  • Golf
  • Hockey
  • Motorsports
  • Nascar
  • Soccer
  • Tennis
  • UFC

Live Betting & Streaming

Much like most other sportsbooks, BetStars NJ allows bettors to place a variety of different wagers on sporting events. If you’re looking for a higher price, you’ll be able to add up to 20 selections to create a parlay bet. Furthermore, BetStars also offers a parlay bonus on all sports. The minimum requirements make this perk accessible for most bettors – if you win on a parlay with three or more selections at minimum odds of -200, BetStars will boost your winnings.

Here is a full comprehensive list of the different types of bets that you can place with BetStars NJ:

  • Single bets
  • Parlays
  • Round robins
  • Spread betting
  • Over/under betting
  • In-play betting

In-Play Betting
BetStars also offers in-play betting, for live sporting events, including NFL, NHL, NBA and MLB matches.

The process for placing a live bet is simple and straightforward, in fact, it is virtually identical to placing a pre-match bet.


Bet $25 and get a $5 free bet

One of BetStars’ weekly promotions, all you have to do is place a $25 bet on a market of your choice, and you will receive a $5 free bet.

Tuesday Happy Hour

When placing certain qualifying bets with BetStars on a Tuesday night between 6 and 7 pm, you could receive a free bet worth $100, at random.

Parlay bonus

BetStars NJ offers a parlay bonus on all sports. If you win on a parlay with three or more selections, with minimum odds of -200, BetStars will boost your winnings.

Spin & Bet

BetStars NJ’s unique Spin & Bet gives players the chance to multiply their winnings up to a maximum of 10 times. This is only available on selected events and bets up to $100.

Stars Rewards Program
The Stars Rewards program is a loyalty scheme available across all of the Stars Group’s platforms including BetStars, PokerStars and PokerStarsCasino. Every time you place real money bets on a Stars platform, you will earn reward points. Collect the reward points to fill your progress bar and win chests full of special rewards, including cash bonus offers, free play and StarCoins which can redeem in the Rewards store.

There are six types of chests you can win by playing real money games:

  • Red Chest – rewards add up to a value of $50
  • Blue chest – rewards add up to a value of $100
  • Bronze chest – rewards add up to a value of $250
  • Silver chest – rewards add up to a value of $500
  • Gold chest – rewards add up to a value of $750
  • Platinum chest – rewards add up to a value of $1000

All of the rewards in these chests are personalized and tailored specifically to you, so you’ll be sure to get rewards and bonuses that you find useful.

App Review

When launching online sports betting operations in New Jersey, BetStars clearly focused all of their efforts on to their mobile sports betting app. Up until January 2019, you could only bet with BetStars NJ if you downloaded the mobile app. You can download the BetStars NJ app from the BetStars NJ website.

In terms of betting markets, the app offers the same options that are available on the BetStars NJ site. The app also caters to new bettors just like the BetStars site, the app features a ‘popular’ and ‘trending bets’ section.

There is, however, one small gripe we have with the BetStars NJ mobile app. The app only allows users to view a limited number of betting options from the home page at one time. While this seems like an attempt to declutter the display on the smaller screen, we’d quite like to see a wider range of options at a glance. Fortunately, this issue isn’t detrimental to the overall betting experience, as there is an expandable menu.


BetStars NJ is the sports betting branch of the Stars Group, a well-established online gambling company that has licenses to operate in 17 different jurisdictions across the world. All of its services are available in Europe, North America and other parts of the world. Although they may be newcomers when it comes to US sports betting, they have a long-standing track record of delivering fantastic sports betting experiences in many different parts of the world.


BetStars NJ allows you to deposit funds into your account using a wide range of payment methods. You can deposit from any of the Stars platforms, as they all share a single wallet. These funds will be available for wagering on the BetStars platform.  You can deposit funds using the BetStars mobile app or website on a desktop platform.

When it’s time to withdraw, BetStars NJ usually takes three working days to process payout requests. However, the time it will take for the winnings to be reflected in your account depends on the method you use. For instance, withdrawing funds using the Resorts Atlantic City Cage takes just two hours.

Unfortunately, betting with BetStars means going through a lengthy withdrawal process. When withdrawing money from your account you will be required to complete an extensive four-step process to verify your identity when withdrawing winnings.

First, you must submit your name, gender date of birth, the last four digits of your social security number and mobile phone number. From here you must confirm your address. The third step is answering security questions you made when creating the account. Lastly, you must agree to the terms of service.

We understand the importance of security and commend BetStars NJ on the approach they have taken when it comes to player security but when compared to other sports betting platforms the process is fairly cumbersome.

Banking Method Type Deposit Withdrawal
Instant e-checks Digital banking Yes Yes
Neteller e-wallet Yes Yes
PokerStars Play+ Card e-wallet Yes Yes
Resorts Atlantic City Cage Cash Yes Yes
Skrill e-wallet Yes Yes
Paypal e-wallet Yes Yes
Visa Credit/Debit card Yes Yes
Mastercard Credit card Yes No
Stars Transfer Bank transfer Yes No
Pay Near Me Cash Yes No

Safety and security

BetStars NJ makes great effort to maintain high levels of player security and safety. In order to use the BetStars NJ app you must be at least 21 years old and a New Jersey resident. To enforce this the app uses age verification and geolocation technology.

BetStars NJ also prides itself on ensuring its customers gamble responsibly. There are measures in place such as the ability to set time, deposit and loss limits. BetStars also allows users to set time outs and make self-exclusion requests. BetStars even allows its users to close their account for a set period of time.

Site design

BetStars NJ can be accessed using an online web browser, as well as the BetStars NJ mobile sports betting app. If you have an account with PokerStars or PokerStars Casino the same account can be used to access the BetStars platform.

Our Verdict

All things considered, BetStars NJ is one of the more exciting sports betting options available in New Jersey, with a strong selection of pre-match and in-play betting markets, as well as a host of exciting promotions. While the welcome bonus isn’t as rewarding as that of many other top sportsbooks, we think the product makes BetStars NJ the best sports betting app available in the Garden State. If you’re after an exciting mobile betting experience and a variety of markets to bet on, BetStars is sure to deliver. Sound like your ideal bookie? Sign up at Betstars NJ today to take advantage of the new player sign up bonus of up to $500!

Sign me up now!